Sponsored Ads

Search JC Economics Essays

Custom Search

“Economic indicators such as real GDP per capita are the best way of measuring standards of living in a country”. Discuss. [25]


Introduction, Definitions, and Approach to Essay

This Economics essay discusses if economic indicators are the best way of measuring standards of living in a country. One such economic indicator is Gross Domestic Product. What is Gross Domestic Product (GDP)? Nominal GDP is defined as the nominal money value of all final goods and services produced by factors of production located domestically within a country, over a given time period, usually a year. 


Nominal GDP is often converted to real GDP, which measures the level of real output in an economy. Real output refers to the actual physical amount of goods and services produced, whereas in contrast nominal output refers to merely the money value of the goods and services produced. 

Per capita refers to the fact that real GDP has to be divided amongst the population of the country, so that it represents the output per person in a country. 


Why is this important? If a country’s national income has increased together with its population, we need to determine the national income per person, GDP per capita, the total output per person, in order to determine whether average output levels have actually risen. This is important because if Country A has both higher real national income and a larger population compared to Country B, the real GDP per capita for both countries is required for a fair and justifiable comparison of material living standards to be made. 

What are material living standards? Material living standards can be measured by economic indicators such as GDP and GNP (Gross National Product), where a country’s income level represents the ability of its residents to consume goods and services. The higher the national income, the greater the potential level of consumption, hence, the higher the material living standards.

Calculation and Interpretation Problems

However, there are problems in calculation and interpretation when using real GDP per capita to measure the standards of living in a country. 


First, the calculation problems in this respect include data collection problems, underground activities that are not recorded in GDP due to illegality and other reasons, and non-marketed activities which are not recorded in GDP. 



Secondly, interpretation problems include income distribution, composition of output, leisure and stress levels, negative externalities, differences in climate and intangibles.



All these will be discussed in this Economics paper. 

Data Collection Problems

First, data collection problems occur when mistakes arise due to the large numbers of firms and households that governments need to collect information from. This problem may be particularly serious in Less Developed Countries (LDCs) because of possible widespread illiteracy. Without the ability to read or write, some residents in LDCs are unable to fill in forms to accurately declare their income. 


This is often compounded by the problems of geography and inaccessible locations. Economic activities in geographically-inaccessible areas are also likely to be omitted because of poor transportation and telecommunications infrastructure, resulting in the standard of living in that particular country being understated, because these activities might raise the standard of living but simply cannot be measured or collected in the form of usable data.

"Underground" and Non-marketed Output

Furthermore, output that is non-marketed is not recorded in national income statistics even though they generate welfare for society. For example, the value of DIY (do-it-yourself) furniture, and DIY renovation, home-cooked meals, mothers' love, and childcare provided by parents or relatives are not recorded, while they contribute to standard of living. 


Also, particularly in developing countries (LDCs) such as some countries in Sub Saharan Africa, where there is often much subsistence farming, where people can grow crops and often rear animals for personal consumption, the size of the non-marketed economy can be quite substantial and the standard of living could be massively understated.

Differences in Climate and Weather

Also, differences in climate across different countries may also cause the standard of living measured by real GDP per capita to be less accurate, because countries in colder climates tend to spend more on clothing, insulation, and heating. Thus, while such expenditure raises real national income, their living standards are actually overstated as compared to other countries with better climates as these other countries spend less on clothing, insulation, and heating. Conversely, countries in the tropics also probably spend more than temperate countries on air conditioning, which will overstate their living standards as compared to countries in more temperate regions.

Stress and Other Intangibles

As an economy develops, people often end up working longer hours or more intensively. Many jobs also change from being routine to being more complex. With less leisure and greater stress, the rise in standard of living tends to be overstated by rises in national income. When comparing between countries, the standard of living would possibly be overstated for the country with relatively longer working hours, with poorer work-life balance, and possibly a more stressful work environment.


However, let's go one step further. Although calculation errors could be minimised as countries develop, currently there are few feasible solutions. Underground and non-marketed activities could be estimated by the values of such activities but those estimates are subjective and inaccurate. Hence GDP per capita still has its problems and limitations in measuring the standards of living in a country. GDP per capita could only measure the material standard of living and is unable to measure the non-quantifiable aspects of the country standards of living.

Alternative Ways of Measuring Standard of Living

On the other hand, economic indicators that measure material standard of living are not the only means of measuring standard of living. There are also other alternative ways to measure the standard of living in a country. 


Various Other Development Indicators



Examples include specific development indicators such as healthcare indicators, like life expectancy and infant mortality rates, while examples of education indicators include literacy rates and proportion of the population having primary, secondary, and tertiary education levels. Consumption indicators like the number of TV sets, refrigerators and telephone lines per capita are also commonly used. 



HDI and MEW



Two famous alternative indicators are discussed here - HDI and MEW. 



The Human Development Index (HDI) concept, originally suggested by research from the famous economist Amartya Sen, comprises data on PPP-adjusted GDP per capita, school enrolment, adult literacy, and life expectancy. The central economic idea here is that human development depends on the quantity of resources available to the people in the country, their ability to use the goods and services and the time they have to use these goods and services and the time they have to use these goods and services. 



Measure of Economic Welfare (MEW) comprises data on national income, with allowances made for leisure, non-marketed output, and services contributed by existing consumer durables. Offsetting deductions are made for “regrettables”, such as expenditure on commuting to work, national defence, law enforcement, negative externalities, and initial expenditure on consumer durables. 



While both approaches, HDI and MEW, are quite comprehensive in their attempt to capture a wide range of economic and non-economic factors affecting society's living standards, including the non- quantifiable aspects, estimating monetary values of some areas can be rather subjective and spurious, although this is a salutary corrective already.

Conclusions

In conclusion, while by using GDP per capita to measure the standard of living may have its limits, however, by using a uniformly accepted economic indicator of standard of living is arguably better than using economic indicators with differing opinions, standpoints, philosophies, and perspectives to compare across different countries. In fact, standards of living itself is hard to be defined, and thus GDP per capita with its uniformly accepted system may only be used to generalise the standard of living of different countries. 

JC Economics Essays: Tutor's Comments - This H2 economics essay on development and standard of living was adapted, edited, and changed from some essay contributions on my companion website. It is very well written, and has many good aspects to learn from. However, do please note that this was not written under "A" level timed examination conditions, which tend to be stressful, as A levels are time-based, difficult examinations with pressure.  Also, special thanks to MA for her suggestions on highlighting and bolding words that are important for the essay; unfortunately, this Economics blog is for Economics Essays and it's much too difficult to include a glossary. Thanks for reading and cheers!

Sponsored Ads

Please do NOT Plagiarise or Copy Economics Essays

It is one thing to learn how to write good economics essays from sample or model economics essays, but another thing if you plagiarise or copy. Do not copy economics essays.

First, if you are handing in an assignment online, there are checkers online which track sources (such as turnitin). Please craft assignments yourself. Second, if you are handing in a handwritten essay, if you copy, you will not learn and will thus not benefit, nor earn good grades when the real economics examination rolls round. Third, you can always write better essays given time and improvement. Fourth, copying is illegal under most conditions. Do not copy economics essays.

This is an economics site for you to learn how to write good economics essays by reading a range of useful articles on writing, study essay responses and contributions and sample/ model economics essays from students, teachers, and editors. We hope you can learn useful and relevant writing skills in the field of economics from our economics site. Thank you for reading and cheers!